Skip to Main Content

Don Mahone

Vice President, Surety

Contact
Don Mahone
Print

Don Mahone serves as Vice President, Surety for Marsh Agency’s business insurance division. He is responsible for serving clients, supporting the surety team, and helping Marsh Agency deliver thoughtful, effective solutions. He works closely with clients, contractors, carriers, and colleagues to understand needs, evaluate opportunities, structure programs, and help them navigate the surety marketplace.

Don has 12 years of experience in the insurance industry and has received praise for his sound judgment, responsiveness, strong relationships, and attention to detail. Before joining Marsh Agency, he served as RVP, Commercial Surety at Allianz Trade and spent close to a decade with Liberty Mutual Insurance, where he developed a strong foundation in surety, client service, and relationship management.

Don believes the industry is changing quickly and that clients need advisors who can anticipate emerging risks, explain implications clearly, and help them make informed decisions.

“Client advocacy means putting the client’s interests at the center of the relationship while providing objective, informed, and practical advice,” he says. “My goal is for clients to feel that we are genuinely invested in their success and prepared to stand beside them when they need us most.”

Integrity, preparation, accountability, and respect are the core principles that guide Don’s work. He values honesty, clear communication, and follow-through, and he believes expertise is most valuable when it helps people make better decisions. He is also driven by the opportunity to help clients and colleagues succeed while contributing to the continued growth of Marsh Agency’s surety business.

“The strongest proof is the trust I have earned from clients, colleagues, and surety partners over time,” he says. “People rely on me to provide honest advice, follow through on commitments, and remain engaged when an issue becomes complicated. Being named the first ’35 under 35′ RISE recipient from Surety was an especially meaningful recognition of my commitment to leadership, collaboration, and excellence.”

Don lives in Burr Ridge, IL, with his wife and three children, including a set of twins. His family keeps him busy, but he also enjoys attending sporting events, reading, and working out.

Fact File:

Education
  • Illinois State University (Normal, IL): Bachelor of Science in Finance
  • Benedictine University (Lisle, IL): Master of Business Administration with a concentration in Business Analytics
Professional Designations & Licensing
  • Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU)
  • Associate in Surety and Fidelity Bonds (AFSB)
Professional Background
  • Marsh Agency
    • Vice President, Surety (October 2026 – Present) 
  • Allianz Trade
    • RVP, Commercial Surety (March 2024 – October 2026)
    • Regional Commercial Surety Manager (March 2023 – March 2024) 
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
    • Underwriting Consultant (Now Executive Underwriter) (October 2022 – April 2023)
    • Field Product Line Underwriting Specialist (July 2015 – October 2022)
    • College Hire Development Program (June 2014 – July 2015)
Professional Recognition & Awards
  • “35 Under 35” recipient by RISE (honoring rising leaders in the insurance industry)
Industry & Community Involvement
  • Surety Association of Illinois: Former President
  • Pleasant Dale Park District (Burr Ridge, IL): T-Ball coach, ages 4-6
  • Autism Speaks Midwest: Volunteer