Skip to main content
1.800.383.8283
Library
  • Industries
    • Construction
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing
    • Moving & Storage
    • Municipal
    • Non-profit
    • Welding Supply & Gas Dist.
  • Events
  • About
    • History
    • News
    • Office Locations
    • Team
    • Culture
    • Contact
    • Careers at Horton Group
  • Services
  • Online Bill Pay
1.800.383.8283
Client Login
Search

Choose a login.

  • Client Logins
    • Business Insurance
    • Employee Benefits
    • Personal Insurance
  • Library
    • Benefits
    • Commercial
    • Personal
    • Safety
    • Thought Leadership
    • Wellness
Home
1.800.383.8283
  • Business Insurance
  • Employee Benefits
  • Consulting Services
  • Personal Insurance
  • Industries
    • Construction
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing
    • Moving & Storage
    • Municipal
    • Non-profit
    • Welding Supply & Gas Dist.
  • Events
  • About
    • History
    • News
    • Office Locations
    • Team
    • Culture
    • Contact
    • Careers at Horton Group
  • Services
  • Online Bill Pay
  • Library
    • Benefits
    • Commercial
    • Personal
    • Safety
    • Thought Leadership
    • Wellness
      • Population Health Management
  • Client Logins
    • Business Insurance
    • Employee Benefits
    • Personal Insurance
Close Menu
  • Property & Casualty
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Risk Transfer
  • Professional Liability
  • Claims
  • Cyber Liability Insurance
  • Automobile Liability
  • Captives & Alternative Risk
  • International
  • Surety Bond Services
  • Workers Compensation
  • Management Liability
  • ACA/DOL Compliance
  • Core & Voluntary Benefits
  • Executive Benefits
  • FSA / HSA
  • Group Medical
  • International Benefits
  • Private Exchange Technology
  • Retirement Services
  • Stop Loss
  • ThinkHR
  • Zenefits
  • Home Umbrella
  • Life & Health
  • Private Client
  • Speciality Recreation
  • Safety & Loss Control
  • Wellness
‹ Back to Resources

General Liability Covers Data Breaches?.....Not so Fast

April 13, 2016 at 9:00 AM
Share

By Mike Richmond, JD

The United States Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit recently upheld a District Court ruling that a General Liability policy may provide coverage for data breaches.  But, the devil is in the details.  This case emphasizes the need for businesses to obtain standalone cyber coverage.

Travelers Indemnity Company of America v. Portal Healthcare Solutions involved a medical records safekeeping firm, Portal, who suffered a data breach.  The breach led to the publication of the medical records Portal was protecting, which was realized when two individuals Google’d their names.  The first links provided by the search were their medical records.  It was determined that the medical records were available via the internet from November 2, 2012, to March 14, 2013.  This resulted in a class action lawsuit in Federal District Court.

Portal did not have cyber liability coverage in place at the time of the breach.  Instead, they only had a general liability policy through Travelers.  Travelers argued that they had no obligation to defend Portal since their general liability policy did not provide data breach coverage.

However, the District Court found that coverage was provided under the Personal & Advertising Injury section of the general liability policy.  The wording of this section provided that Travelers was obligated to pay damages resulting from “electronic publication of material that....gives unreasonable publicity to a person’s private life.”

In defining these terms, the District Court found that the data breach and online exposure of medical records met the “publication” requirement and that the exposure of the medical records was an “unreasonable” publication of the “private life” (medical records) of those affected.      

Two reasons why standalone cyber liability insurance is still necessary:

First, the issue in this case is narrowly focused on the wording of the Travelers general liability policies in place during the breach.  It does not address cyber liability and its global applicability to general liability policies. 

Since this time, ISO has developed endorsements that revise the language in general liability policies to specifically exclude data breach events.  (See CG 21 06 05 14, CG 21 07 05 14, and CG 08 05 14).  Also, many insurance carriers have included their exclusions in policies limiting their liability for cyber-related losses.

Second, the 4th Circuit represents Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina.  While this case sets a precedent for federal case law in these states, there is no guarantee other federal courts will find this ruling persuasive, even for the narrow issues that were addressed.

While this case provides an interesting perspective on how general liability courts can view policies, the insurance carriers that provide these policies have already taken measures to prevent similar results.  Therefore, standalone cyber liability coverage remains an essential part of all risk management programs.


Material posted on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute a legal opinion or medical advice. Contact your legal representative or medical professional for information specific to your needs.

Insurable + Uninsurable Risk of Cyber

Preparing for cyber-related risks and threats are critical to the sustainability of your organization. Are you prepared for these threats with the right strategy evaluate or mitigate risks?

READ MORE

Mike Richmond, JD

Mike Richmond
Vice President of Sales, Business Insurance
Email / Bio / (312) 989-1435

Mike Richmond works as a business advisor, his job is to analyze every detail of a client's business, determine every exposure, and provide risk management programs to insulate the business from liability. Mike is also an attorney, and studied law at night while working as an insurance consultant.

Mike's legal education gives him an intimate understanding of the liabilities businesses face, as well as the many ways those liabilities can affect businesses.


Footer: Call-To-Action

Contact the Horton Group today to discuss how you can achieve a higher level of performance.

Contact Us

Find Us

Horton Group
Corporate Headquarters / Orland Park, IL
(800) 383-8283

Bourbonnais, IL
Chicago, IL
Edina, MN
Estero, FL
Indianapolis, IN
South Bend, IN
Sturgis, MI
Waukesha, WI 

  • About
  • News
  • Our Team
  • Career
  • Office Locations
  • Contact
  • Forms & Applications
  • Assurex Global
  • Awards
  • Privacy Policy

Join Our Mailing List!

Sign up to receive email notifications for upcoming events and important industry news.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Copyright Menu

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Ethics Reporting System
  • Compensation Disclosure
Copyright © 2021 The Horton Group